Scarlet Deer Inn Collectible Tracker

Track the ten missable toys for All Together, plus Horace as a separate story object. Full locations: Toys & Collectibles. Method: All Toys.

Why this list matches All Together

All ten rows above are missable underground toys. Horace is tracked separately because he is a story quest object, not part of the ten. Patch 1.014 fixed All Together unlocking early — you need all ten ticks for the real Steam badge.

How to hunt with this tracker

1. Horace is secured during the opening — tick when the story thread is clear
2. Underground: solve → shortcut → light → search — Labyrinth
3. Never tick hopeful guesses; only tick confirmed picks
4. Pair with All Toys and Achievements

Search window reminder

If chase audio is active, close this checklist mentally and run your prepared route. Return to looting after braziers and doors are stable. See Survive Chase and Find Shortcuts.

Why buckets instead of fake coordinates

Community-verified directions stay useful when hand-painted rooms differ by patch. If a row stays empty, re-sweep that section using Toys & Collectibles hints.

Pairing with achievements

When a Steam unlock sounds collection-flavored, confirm the relevant boxes here, then tick the achievement checklist community label. Keep both honest — community trackers, not invented official schemas.

Emotional note

Toys in this game foreshadow and remember child-world stakes around Kuba and Bara. If tracking starts to feel like poking a bruise, stop. Story completion does not require perfect shelves. Boundaries: Who Should Play. Spoilers: Ending Explained.

Cleanup route after credits

1. Village inn + Dorota + cake triangle shelves
2. Church/oak edges if still accessible in your state
3. Apiary/cellar leftovers
4. Underground hubs behind shortcuts
5. Escape-adjacent optional rooms only with torch discipline

Key props context: Key items. Torch skill: Use the Torch.

Carry the tracker as lightly as Horace — useful, meaningful, never more important than getting Elise through the dark alive.

First-pass minimum vs completionist maximum

Minimum meaningful set: Horace secured, plus any toys you naturally see in village banking.
Completionist maximum: all buckets ticked, then reconcile with Steam achievements.

Choose consciously. Defaulting to maximum while emotionally exhausted is how players sour on a good story.

Multi-device warning

Browser local storage does not magically follow you from desktop Chrome to Deck browser. If you swap devices, keep a manual note or retick carefully.

Spoiler-safe co-op tracking

A friend can operate this checklist while you play if they promise not to read ending pages aloud. Stick to item names and room buckets only.

When a bucket stays empty

Empty is information. It means “sweep this region again,” not “the game broke.” Revisit with torch corner paints after the next story flag.

Close the loop with key items

If you are unsure whether something was a toy or a key, check Key items. Tick here only for collectible-class objects you actually picked up.